Softball and baseball are often compared, but they are distinct sports with unique styles and challenges. One of the most notable differences lies in pitching. While the mechanics are fascinating in their own ways, the conversation has taken on new significance following the online backlash faced by softball star Karlyn Pickens, who recently made history on the mound.
In baseball, pitchers throw overhand from a raised mound 60 feet, 6 inches from the back of home plate. This motion generates high velocities often above 90 mph and gives batters slightly more time to react. The challenge is clear, but it’s commonly misunderstood how this compares to softball.
Softball pitchers use an underhand motion from just 43 feet away. Although the ball may travel slower on a radar gun, the reduced distance significantly cuts down the batter’s reaction time. A 70 mph softball pitch can feel equivalent to a 100 mph baseball pitch because of how quickly it reaches the plate.
This difference often fuels the misconception that softball is “easier.” Many assume that because baseball pitches are faster, the sport must be more difficult. But when reaction time is considered, hitting a softball can be equally if not more challenging. Studies support this, showing that softball hitters have the same or less time to decide and react than their baseball counterparts.
Physically, the strain on pitchers in both sports is remarkably similar. Despite different motions, research shows that the stress on shoulders and elbows is nearly equal. This debunks the myth that one sport requires less athleticism or strength than the other.
On March 24, 2025, Karlyn Pickens made headlines by throwing the fastest pitch ever recorded in a softball game. What should have been a historic achievement instead attracted a wave of online mockery.
Social media comment sections were filled with dismissive remarks, mainly from teenage boys, saying things like, “That’s slow, I’d hit that 450 dead center,” or “I was hitting that speed in 5th grade.”
These comments didn’t just miss the point, they highlighted a deeper issue in sports culture: the tendency to undermine women athletes, especially online.
Softball and baseball may look similar, but the broader context often gets overlooked. College softball represents the sport’s highest level for women, while MLB players benefit from longer careers, elite facilities, and full-time development. Yet somehow, female college athletes are constantly held to pro-level male standards and judged unfairly.
A real-world comparison helps. Alex Derlago, a JV baseball player from Wilsonville High School, shared his perspective after facing softball pitching firsthand: “When I was trying to hit the softball they came in like a blink of an eye, I think it’s definitely harder to hit a softball speed wise, it’s a lot closer.”
Understanding the mechanics is only part of the equation. Karlyn Pickens didn’t just throw a fast pitch; she threw a spotlight on how far we still have to go in giving women athletes the respect they earn every day.
Before judging female athletes, it’s worth learning the facts, or stepping into the box yourself.